We live in a society where networking, both for our personal and work lives, is extremely important. Information needs to be passed on from one person to another or to a group of people. We need to stay in touch with one another. Throughout history we have been creating, developing and enhancing our methods of communication. First it was grunts and hand gestures, then languages were developed. Once we had language we needed to develop ways to communicate over large distances, so we developed postal services and eventually the telephone. In our modern day we have a wonderful communication technology in the form of the internet, limitless amounts of information can be shared almost instantaneously to millions of people.
Email has become, in my opinion, the epitome of convenient communication. I do not find it to be a substitute for talking to a person, but for just getting information to another person, it is quite effective. Unfortunately, there are new types of communication evolving. Social networking sites like Facebook, Myspace, et al. These sites focus around the sharing of information, messages, photos and games.
Most of my friends know that I detest Facebook, I hate the other social networking sites as well, but I tend to focus my dislike on Facebook because it’s become so dominant in our culture. I do, however, have an account that I check semi-regularly, and I do find a few of their games to be fun, and it is interesting to see what some of your old acquaintances are up to. While there are some good qualities to Facebook, I’ve come to the conclusion that its fundamental flaws outweigh its flare. I’m not going to nitpick the details of how Facebook works, I will, however, talk about a few of the major qualms I have about this networking site.
- Facebook forces social conformity
We need to communicate in our modern world, it’s both a necessity to function and for many of us, a desire to feel connected with our friends and family. The creators of Facebook and other social networking sites understand this and base their programs/sites around our this concept. For Facebook to be successful, it needs a large user base and all other social networking services to have a small user base.
The only way to accomplish this is to limit its features to users only. There can be no communication (aside from invitations to join Facebook) between members and non-members. And as more people begin to use Facebook, they begin to communicate only on Facebook. Of course this means that if you are not a member of Facebook, you’re no longer in communication with your friends, family and in some cases your co-workers and employers.
I have friends in the English department who have official Facebook groups for their university classes where they hold discussions regarding their readings. A close friend of mine is a member of a work related Facebook group where he gets messages regarding his work. Many of my friends use Facebook to organize events and birthday parties which you can only be invited to if you use Facebook.
This may sound absurd, but you can actually become socially isolated if you choose to not use these social networking sites if your friends/family/co-workers rely on them.
- Facebook encourages shallow communication
As more and more people continue to use Facebook, they use other means of communication less and less. Email gets replaced by wall messages. Birthday cards (or e-cards from Hallmark for use poor grad students) are replaced with something from the Free Gift Application. Event invitations are replaced with Facebook event invitations. I actually received a Facebook Wedding invitation the other month.
Instead of having in-depth conversations with people, we’re having more and more shallow conversations with people. For the most part, Facebook is open to all your friends to view. Most conversations you have with someone will be shared with all that can see your page. You don’t want to be too personal so you keep your messages short. In addition, for many people, typing takes time, and we want quick and fast communication.
So the result is short messages (usually written with bad grammar, spelling and punctuation).
“Happy Birthday”
“U R CUTE!!!11″
“funny hat!!! luv that pic”
I’m a bit of a personal person. I don’t want everyone to know everything about my life. But at the same time, there are people that I like to share with more than others. I also have different groups of friends, I have friends from highschool, and I have friends from university. I don’t always want my friends from highschool to know that I’m frustrated with my scholarship applications, nor do I want my family to know that some of my friends went drinking last night.
Also, and this may be a more unique situation to me than to a general audience, but there are a few close friends that know I’m transsexual. I’m glad I can confide in them, however I have to limit what and how I talk to them because there are other people (like my very catholic godmother who might possibly have a heart attack if she learned about my transsexuality in an untimely fashion) for whom I need to keep some information private.
Yes I know there are privacy settings I can use for individual users. Yes I could go through and fix it so that certain people can only see certain aspects of my profile, but with 200+ friends¹ that would be quite a complex task, especially with the enormous number of applications and ways to share information.
I could go on, but I think that anything else I write would just be specific little rants I have about Facebook. Instead, I think I’ll be somewhat hypocritical and go post about this entry on Twitter².
-Floating
1. When I say friends here I’m meaning the friends on Facebook. These people are not necessarily my friends, most are just people I’ve met in life at some point who found my profile and wanted to ‘add me’ as their friend.
2. Just another social networking site of a different kind. ^_^